High Court Bends Over Backwards to Resolve Family Will Dispute

Newspaper columns are full of legal cases with crushing costs of litigation and it is easy to lose sight of the fact that it is the role of judges to resolve disputes as efficiently and cheaply as possible. In a recent case (Seals and Another V Williams; CHD 15 MAY 2015) the High Court has done just that in bending over backwards to achieve a settlement of a bitter family will dispute.

Two sons had launched proceedings, challenging their father’s will by which he left everything he owned, including his £675,000 share of the family farm, to a childhood friend. The dispute had generated a great deal of acrimony and the positions of the parties were in danger of becoming entrenched.

An attempt at mediation had largely stalled and it was to the credit of lawyers on both sides that they had encouraged the parties to settle their differences. To that end, the Court took the rare step of directing that a judge should carry out a ‘Neutral Evaluation’ of the strength of the arguments on each side.

That swift and relatively low cost procedure, whilst not leading to a formal judgment, would result in non-binding recommendations as to the likely outcome of the case which would be likely to assist in achieving a settlement. The Court noted that the use of such a fast-track procedure was possible under the Court’s inherent jurisdiction to control proceedings and was to be ‘warmly welcomed’.

The requirements of each client and each case will often vary, but in every case, Askews Legal LLP’s primary aim is to settle clients’ disputes quickly and cost effectively. We are passionate advocates of mediation, but where needed, have the skills and experience to achieve the best outcome for you at trial.

Askews Legal LLP – Experts in the field of civil and commercial litigation in Coventry and Warwickshire.

Contact Kuljeet for more details. Click Here or call us on 02476 231000. Confidentiality and discretion assured.