Request a callback

If you want to discuss a particular service or need help, call us on 02476 231000.

What an Investigation by the Serious Fraud Office Means for Business Owners

The Serious Fraud Office (SFO) is the enforcement entity behind the UK’s effort to combat serious and complex fraud, bribery, and corruption. Established in 1987 under the Criminal Justice Act, it is charged with investigating and prosecuting the most severe and complex economic crimes.

What Triggers an SFO Investigation?

Several factors can trigger an SFO investigation:

  1. Whistleblowers: Employees, competitors, or other insiders may report suspicious activities.
  2. Regulatory Referrals: Regulatory bodies like the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) may refer cases to the SFO.
  3. Self-Reporting: Companies may self-report potential misconduct to obtain more lenient treatment.
  4. Media Reports: High-profile allegations in the media can prompt the SFO to initiate an investigation.
  5. Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs): Financial institutions and other entities are required to file SARs if they suspect money laundering or other financial crimes.

What is the SFO investigation process?

An SFO investigation typically follows several key stages:

Initial Assessment

When the SFO receives information suggesting serious fraud or corruption, it conducts a preliminary assessment to determine whether a full investigation is warranted. This involves reviewing evidence, assessing the scale and impact of the alleged misconduct, and considering the potential for successful prosecution.

Formal Investigation

If the SFO decides to proceed, it launches a formal investigation. This phase involves gathering evidence through various means:

  1. Dawn Raids: One of the most dramatic tools at the SFO’s disposal is the dawn raid. This involves unannounced visits to business premises or homes to seize documents, computers, and other evidence. Businesses must have protocols in place to handle such raids, including immediate legal consultation.
  2. Interviews: The SFO will interview witnesses and suspects, often under caution, meaning anything said can be used in court. Businesses must ensure employees understand their rights and obligations during these interviews.
  3. Document Requests: The SFO can issue Section 2 Notices under the Criminal Justice Act 1987, compelling the production of documents and information. Failure to comply can result in criminal charges.
  4. International collaboration: Most cases referred to the SFO are cross-jurisdictional. Evidence from international enforcement agencies will need to be gathered and analysed. This can take many months or even years.
  5. Decision to prosecute: The progress of an investigation is overseen by a case controller who regularly reviews the evidence to see if it is worth continuing. They will decide whether the evidence gathered provides a realistic prospect of conviction and whether a prosecution would be in the public interest.

Deferred Prosecution Agreements (DPAs)

A significant development in corporate criminal liability is the Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA). Introduced in the UK in 2014, DPAs allow companies to avoid prosecution by agreeing to certain conditions, such as paying fines, implementing compliance programs, and cooperating with ongoing investigations. DPAs provide a pathway for companies to rectify issues without the reputational damage of a conviction.

The Role of Legally Privileged Information

During an SFO investigation, legal privilege in relation to documents and communications is vital. Privilege protects interactions between a Solicitor and their client, ensuring they cannot be disclosed without the client’s consent. There are two main types of privilege:

  1. Legal Advice Privilege: Covers communications between Solicitors and their clients for the purpose of seeking or giving legal advice.
  2. Litigation Privilege: Applies to communications made for the dominant purpose of litigation, covering documents created with a view to ongoing or reasonably anticipated legal proceedings.

Business owners must be vigilant in maintaining privilege, especially during internal investigations, to prevent inadvertent disclosures.

How Legal expertise can help in SFO investigations

The complexity and severity of an SFO investigation necessitate robust legal support. Legal counsel can assist in several critical areas:

Preparation

  1. Compliance Programs: Developing and maintaining robust compliance programs can mitigate risks. This includes regular training, internal audits, and clear reporting mechanisms.
  2. Crisis Management Plans: Having a crisis management plan in place ensures a swift and organised response to dawn raids and other investigative actions.
  3. Internal Investigations: Conducting thorough internal investigations can identify issues early, enabling proactive measures.

Response

  1. Representation: Legal counsel provides representation during interviews and negotiations with the SFO, ensuring the protection of rights and interests.
  2. Negotiations: Experienced lawyers can negotiate DPAs, striving for outcomes that balance accountability with business continuity.
  3. Privilege Protection: Ensuring the preservation of legal privilege during investigations to safeguard sensitive communications.

Wrapping up

An investigation by the Serious Fraud Office is a significant event for any business, potentially leading to severe financial, legal, and reputational consequences. Understanding what triggers an investigation, the process involved, and the role of legal privilege is crucial for effective management.

Legal guidance is indispensable in navigating the complexities of an SFO investigation. From preparation to response, skilled solicitors can help businesses mitigate risks, protect their interests, and achieve the most favourable outcomes possible. For business owners, investing in legal expertise is a proactive step towards safeguarding their operations against the potentially devastating impact of serious fraud and corruption allegations.

If the SFO is investigating you, please call our office today on 02476 231000 or email enquiries@askewslegal.co

Please note that this article is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.